IRS-Aligned Calculations No Data Sent to Servers 2026 Tax Law

LLC vs S-Corp Comparison

Free
$
$
$
Difference in Total Tax
$0
Enter a profit to compare the two structures.
LLC self-employment tax
$0
LLC federal income tax
$0
LLC total tax
$0
S-corp payroll tax (both halves)
$0
S-corp federal income tax
$0
S-corp total including admin
$0
The difference is what the profit above your salary is taxed at. An LLC pays 15.3% self-employment tax on the whole profit. An S-corp pays payroll tax only on a reasonable salary and nothing on the distribution, so the saving is roughly 15.3% of the profit above the salary, minus the cost of running payroll.
15.3% self-employment tax · 92.35% of profit is taxable · 7.65% employer payroll share · $184,500 wage base

How each structure is taxed

A single-member LLC is ignored for federal income tax. The owner reports the profit on Schedule C and pays self-employment tax on 92.35% of it: 12.4% for Social Security up to the $184,500 wage base, plus 2.9% for Medicare with no cap. Half of the resulting tax is deductible, which reduces income tax but does not reduce the self-employment tax itself.

An S-corp is also a pass-through, but the owner must be paid a salary. That salary carries payroll tax of 6.2% plus 1.45% on each side, 15.3% in total, exactly like any employee. The rest of the profit is a distribution, and distributions carry no Social Security or Medicare tax at all. Income tax applies to the salary plus the distribution, so the profit is taxed once either way; only the payroll tax changes.

That is why the comparison is really about one number: the size of the profit that escapes payroll tax. If the salary is 40% of profit, 60% escapes, and the saving is about 15.3% of that 60% before fees.

LLC vs S-corp at different profit levels

Single filer, salary set at 40% of profit, S-corp admin cost of $1,200, federal tax only.

Net profitS-corp salaryLLC total taxS-corp total taxResult
$75,000$30,000$17,101$8,735S-corp saves $8,367
$100,000$40,000$25,745$11,973S-corp saves $13,772
$150,000$60,000$43,385$20,340S-corp saves $23,045
$200,000$80,000$61,580$29,664S-corp saves $31,917
$300,000$120,000$94,209$49,291S-corp saves $44,918

The advantage grows with profit because the self-employment tax base grows with it while the payroll tax base stays fixed at the salary. At $75,000 of profit the S-corp saves about $8,400 after the admin cost; at $300,000 it saves about $44,900. The gap tracks the profit that escapes payroll tax, which is why the election is popular at higher profit levels.

Why the salary cannot be arbitrary

The saving comes entirely from the gap between profit and salary, so the temptation is to set the salary as low as possible. The IRS blocks that with the reasonable compensation rule: an S-corp must pay a shareholder-employee reasonable compensation for the services actually performed before any distribution is made.

There is no safe harbour and no published percentage. The test is what you would pay a replacement to do the same job, and courts have looked at training, duties, time devoted, and what comparable businesses pay. A consultant billing $200,000 of profit who pays themselves $40,000 is the classic fact pattern that gets adjusted.

Set the salary field to something you could defend in an audit, then look at the saving. If the answer only works at an implausible salary, the answer is no.

What this calculator leaves out

  • QBI deduction. Both structures can claim it, and the 2026 rules changed: the deduction is now the greater of the standard computation or a new minimum deduction for active qualified business income, so a flat 20% is no longer the ceiling. Leaving it out keeps the comparison about payroll tax.
  • State tax. Some states tax S-corp distributions differently, and a few charge franchise or entity-level tax that an LLC avoids.
  • Payroll and filing costs. Captured in the admin field, but quotes vary widely.
  • Reasonable compensation risk. Not modelled, because it is a judgement, not a formula.

For the payroll side on its own, the payroll tax calculator breaks out employer Social Security, Medicare and FUTA. The self-employment tax calculator handles the LLC side in more detail.

Frequently asked questions

No, and the deciding factor is the salary. The saving is the self-employment tax you stop paying on the profit above the salary, minus the payroll tax you start paying on the salary, minus the cost of running payroll. At a salary of 40% of profit that is a win from roughly $30,000 of profit upward. If the reasonable salary is close to the full profit, the saving shrinks to about 1% and the admin cost can cancel it out entirely.

The IRS requires reasonable compensation but publishes no formula or safe harbour. It is what you would pay someone else to do the same work in your industry and location, and it must be reported as W-2 wages before any distribution is taken. Setting it artificially low is the most common audit issue for one-person S-corps.

15.3% on 92.35% of net profit up to the Social Security wage base, then 2.9% plus 0.9% on the portion above the Additional Medicare threshold. On $150,000 of profit that is about $21,194. Half of it is deductible against income tax.

No. That is the entire point. A shareholder-employee pays payroll tax on the salary, and the remaining distribution is not subject to Social Security or Medicare tax. Income tax is still owed on the distribution, because an S-corp is a pass-through.

The qualified business income deduction still exists, but the 2026 rules are not a flat 20% cap. For tax years beginning after 2025 the deduction is the greater of the standard QBI computation or a new minimum deduction for active qualified business income. Because both structures can claim it, this calculator leaves QBI out and compares the taxes that actually differ.

Payroll processing, a separate business return on Form 1120-S, possibly state franchise tax, and the bookkeeping to keep salary and distributions separate. Budget $800 to $2,000 a year at the low end, and edit the admin field above if your quote is different.

Only after the numbers clear the extra cost with a margin, and only with a reasonable salary you can defend. The election is made on Form 2553 and can be revoked, but switching back has consequences for basis and for any built-in gain, so run the comparison at your real profit level first.

Related calculators